Week 5 was the highest scoring week of the season, with four teams cracking triple digits, all higher than 113! And amazingly none of those four teams faced each other, so all got victories. The 977 points posted this week were the most since that same amount was achieved in Week 6 way back in 2021.
The big congratulations go to Unlucky Irish who posted a massive 134 points, in spite of having a tight end only score 1 point and a receiver only score 3 points. You can get by with that, as John did, by having Jahmyr Gibbs score 35, Jason Myers, your kicker, score 23(!), Trevor Lawrence score 21 and the Texans defense score 20. Four players scoring 20 or more is always a good thing. To top it off he had Mike Evans nearly get there by scoring 19. All in all, just a great week, and the highest weekly total we’ve had this season! Nice work big guy! This was John’s first Weekly High Score prize this season, and is the fourth different team to claim one this year.
Across the rest of the league, my Rebels got scalped by Chief Dredd so there are no undefeated teams remaining. The last time anyone even made it to 5-0 was back in 2013 when Timmy’s Channel 4 News Team actually started off 6-0. No one has made it past 4-0 since then. On the other end of the spectrum, American BadAss remains winless after Big Sack No TDs had a Monday Night comeback to win 89-74. The record for worst starting record belongs to Yours Truly, as twice (in a row I might add) my team started off 0-6 (2011 & 2012). In other matchups, James’ renamed “Tip Toeing” and Rob’s Wyld Ass Monkeys notched victories to move into winning records at 3-2.
This week is my annual “Way Too Early” Playoff Predictions! I’m sticking to my same methodology because it’s gotta work this time. More on that below. Also, we give out a Best Bench at a level not seen in years. Let’s. Do. This!!
BIG TIME
- Drake Maye, QB – American BadAss – 41 pts – This is most points scored in a single week by any player this year! This was quite the game for Maye, throwing for 374 yards and 4 TD’s, plus he had 25 yards rushing and another TD.
- Jahmyr Gibbs, RB – Unlucky Irish – 35 pts – Another week north of 30 points for Gibbs which gives him 3 this season in just 5 weeks of action. He was great this week, going for 151 yards and 2 TD’s, plus added 5 catches for 56 yards. He is now the top ranked runningback in fantasy, and it’s not really close. He leads the 2nd place RB (Bijan Robinson) by 27 points.
- Bucky Irving, RB – Joe’s Pats – 32 pts – Coming into the week, Bucky had 31 total points on the season. He just went ahead and doubled that with an amazing week, getting 165 yards on the ground, along with 10 yards receiving and adding both a rushing and receiving TD.
- Jayden Daniels, QB – Unlucky Irish – 30 pts – Who needs a passing game? Daniels threw for just 199 passing yards and no TD’s. But he made up for it by rushing for 103 yards plus getting in the endzone twice!
- Jaylen Warren, RB – Chief Dredd – 30 pts – Warren was all about the long plays this week, gaining 101 yards and a TD on just 15 carries, plus gaining 87 yards receiving on just 6 catches. He averaged nearly 9 yards each time he touched the ball.
COME ON MAN
- Jaylen Waddle, WR – Scottish Rebels – 1 pt – This is the definition of ‘Come On Man’. He was literally 2 yards away from getting 2 more points. He caught 2 passes for 19 yards (could you get just 1 more?), plus had one carry for 9 yards (1 more? Maybe??). Come on man...
- Juwan Johnson, TE – sprouts – 1 pt – Wasn’t for lack of trying… JJ caught 4 of 5 passes thrown his way, but he gained all of 16 yards.
- Jake Ferguson, TE – American BadAss – 1 pt – He did catch 50% of passes thrown his way (3 of 6), but they didn’t go far. He finished with only 19 yards.
- Colston Loveland, TE – Unlucky Irish – 1 pt – Another weak tight end performance. Loveland caught 2 balls for 19 yards. Don’t love that.
- Harold Fanin Jr., TE – Tip Toeing – 0 pts – The tight end failures keep on coming. After scoring 17 and 8 points in the previous two weeks, Harold just went to sleep this week. One catch. Four yards. Zero points.
- Ceedee Lamb, WR – Chief Dredd – 0 pts – Lamb did have a quad injury, and I normally don’t call out injured players in this section. But he actually played after he sustained the injury, so apparently he was healthy enough to continue disappointing everyone. Even after the goose egg this week, Lamb is still the 3rd highest scoring wide receiver so far this season.
CHRIS COLLINSWORTH AUTO-COMMENT GENERATOR:
“Now here’s a guy [insert the most gay thing you can think of related to Patrick Mahomes]”
JOKE OF THE WEEK – GRAMMAR EDITION
Contractions function almost identically to the full two-word phrase, but are only appropriate in some places in a sentence. It’s one of the weird quirks of this language we’ve.
JOKE OF THE WEEK #2 – GRAMMAR EDITION
Some people say the English language is confusing. To which I say, it’s.
PLAYOFFS? DON’T TALK ABOUT PLAYOFFS!! PLAYOFFS??!
Before we dive into this season’s predictions, a quick look back. Over the last 8 seasons, my prediction record is 36 correct and 12 wrong, so I’m right at a 75% success rate. Only once in those 8 seasons have I gone 6-for-6 on my picks, and that was way back in 2020. I’ve gone 5-1 three times, 4-2 another three times, and in 2023 I had my worst showing at 3-3.
Last season was one of the 4-2 finishes, partly due to my not picking Unlucky Irish to make the playoffs. But John’s team became the first team in league history to make it in after starting the season 0-5. Somehow after that brutal start, John managed to battle back to a 7-7 record which nabbed him the first Wildcard spot. Absolutely crazy! So there’s always hope.
In spite of my mixed results, I’m still following the same methodology as in years past: mostly looking at current records, points scored, schedule difficulty and utilization, but also throwing in some gut feelings. You know, part science, part art.
So now without further ado, here are my “Way Too Early” 2026 Playoff Predictions:
Most likely to make it in: Tip Toeing and Scottish Rebels.
James and I are tied for most points scored so far this season with 508. This is the only sure bet left where the top scoring team through 5 weeks has always made it in. So I’m banking on that trend to continue.
Better chance than not: Chief Dredd and Unlucky Irish.
Timmy is tied for the best record in the league at 4-1, which has a 79% playoff qualification rate. Plus he ranks 5th in scoring, which oddly qualifies 75% of the time. Two solid indicators.
John meanwhile ranks 3rd in scoring, literally just one point behind James and I with 507 points. He also has the easiest remaining schedule. (I’m not getting fooled again this season, John!)
Will be tight: Joe’s Pats and sprouts.
Joe ranks 4th in utilization and 6th in points scored, which qualifies ~53% of the time. Not exactly overwhelming odds, but Joe usually figures out a way to scrape together enough players to get in.
For Russ, he ranks 4th in scoring which qualifies ~62% of the time but he does have the most difficult remaining schedule. So it’s gonna be tight.
Teams Not Expected to Make it: Wyld Ass Monkeys, J LUV U LONG TIME, Big Sack No TDs and American BadAss.
For Rob, it was a very tough decision…he has a 3-2 record which is good, and has historically been a good playoff-qualification indicator, but currently ranks 9th in points scored, which is not good. For Shawn, he has the 2nd worst record (1-4) which has only qualified 21% of the time. For Jens, he ranks 8th in points and 10th in utilization, both of which hurt qualification chances. For Jason, he’s got the double whammy of having an 0-4-1 record and is currently the lowest scoring team. Two other times there have been teams to start 0-4-1, and neither time did they qualify. Also, the lowest scoring team through Week 5 has only qualified ~16% of the time.
If history is any guide, I’m probably wrong on two of my picks. The question is, which two? Still a lot of games to be played!
BEST BENCH
Some teams who don’t claim many Best Benches REALLY go for it when they get one. Such is the case with this week’s winner. The bench-improvement-possibility taking the crown this week is a MASSIVE 56 points! This is the highest improvement possibility since Week 2, 2023, over 3 years ago. The Week 5 Best Bench goes to… American BadAss!
Jason needed only three roster moves to get there: D. Maye for D. Prescott +29, P. Washington for Z. Flowers +18 and B. Corum for C. Brown +9. As mentioned, it’s been a while since Jason took a Best Bench, as his last one was in Week 17 of 2024. It was the second longest non-Best Bench streak in the league. (One team holds the current record at nearly 2 years of no Best Benches.)
Four NFL teams are on byes this week and injuries are more present than ever, so make sure to set your rosters. And get those waiver claims in!!




